Guest posting has been declared dead several times in the past decade. It keeps not dying. The reason is that the version that was declared dead, the low-quality link-building version, is not the same as the version that still works.
What killed the bad version
The bad version of guest posting was a link-building strategy. The goal was to place content on any site that would accept it, regardless of quality or relevance, in order to build backlinks that would improve search rankings. The content was often thin, the sites were often low-quality, and the relationship between the guest post and the host publication was purely transactional.
Search engines got better at identifying this pattern. The links from low-quality sites stopped producing the ranking benefit they once did. The strategy that was built around those links stopped working. The people who had been doing it declared guest posting dead and moved on to the next tactic.
What the version that still works looks like
The version of guest posting that still works is not a link-building strategy. It is a credibility-building strategy. The goal is to appear in publications that the target audience reads, in a way that demonstrates expertise and builds association with the publication’s brand.
The practical difference is in the selection criteria. The bad version selected publications based on domain authority. The good version selects publications based on audience relevance. The question is not “what is the DA of this site” but “does the person I want to reach read this publication, and will appearing here make them more likely to trust me?”
What makes a guest post work
The guest posts that build credibility tend to have a few things in common. They say something specific rather than something general. They are written for the publication’s audience rather than for the author’s SEO goals. They include a clear point of view rather than a balanced survey of the topic.
The specific point of view is the most important element. A guest post that says “here are five things to consider about X” is indistinguishable from every other guest post on the topic. A guest post that says “the conventional wisdom about X is wrong, and here is why” is memorable and shareable in a way that the listicle is not.
The relationship with the publication
The guest posts that produce the most long-term value tend to be the ones that are the beginning of a relationship with the publication rather than a one-time placement. The author who becomes a regular contributor to a publication that their target audience reads is building a compounding asset. Each piece adds to the association between the author and the publication’s brand.
The relationship requires treating the publication as a partner rather than a distribution channel. The author who pitches ideas that are genuinely useful to the publication’s audience, who meets deadlines, and who produces work that the editor does not have to heavily revise tends to be invited back. The author who treats the placement as a transaction tends not to be.
Related from Impulsblog: Why email still outperforms every other channel
Related from Impulsblog: What the most successful founders do differently in year one
